.
Feedback

One Dies, Four Rescued After River Boating Accident

One of the five men boating yesterday on the raging Croton River died after rescue.

Croton-on-Hudson's Rescue Dive team rescued the last of five men who plunged into the raging Croton River Sunday while on an inflatable boat. One of the quintet died.

The river was moving at about 40 miles an hour, making it impossible for rescuers to reach one man hanging onto a snagged tree in the middle of the current near Mayo's Landing—either by boat or helicopter—for more than three hours.

Rescuers on either bank of the river could see but not grab him. Finally, the man let go. Twenty seconds later he shot through the length of the snag and three Croton on Hudson Dive Team members plucked him from the water. He had developed hypothermia. 

The incident occurred about about a half-mile northeast of the mouth of the river.

Rain water from Hurricane Irene had raised the speed and level of the river—so much that it lapped at the Metro North trestle bridge at its mouth yesterday morning at the height of the Hudson River tide.

Four other adults who had been on the boat were rescued earlier in the evening. One of the men was given CPR at the scene, but died after he was taken to the hospital. The three others who were rescued are said to be okay.

Police received the call about the boaters at 5:46 p.m.

Return to Patch for updates. 

Mark August 29, 2011 at 12:57 am
it was a blue river raft...
Victor Comte August 29, 2011 at 01:59 am
I passed by when they were pumping air into a blue raft and when I returned from the Dam the raft was ready to launch. The group comprised of young men and their families. I took a picture of the raft. Vic Conte
cococrin August 29, 2011 at 02:55 pm
A joy ride on the river after a hurricane? Really?
marcela August 29, 2011 at 04:41 pm
For a group of grown men to embark on such an adventure the day a severe storm hit the area is nothing short of irresponsible. Among other things, it shows complete disregard for those who had to risk their lives to save them from their own stupidity. Cities and towns around this country should seriously consider issuing fines to citizens for reckless endargenment of a public servant's safety. I'm truly sorry for the man who lost his life but I'm very glad those who rescued them (or attempted to) are doing ok. My deepest admiration goes out to all of them.
Jock Bradley August 29, 2011 at 09:38 pm
It's easy to jump to all sorts of conclusions about the mental capacity of these rafters when you don't know them or their skills. It's also easy to view the sport as and it's participants as being crazy or idiotic when you've never experienced it either at all or at the level that the deceased had for many years. I am a good friend of the person who died and will vouch for his credibility as a very smart, safe and capable paddler.
I am glad that no one else was hurt, especially those that tried so valiantly to save Peter's and the other rafters lives. He never would have wanted anyone to come in harms way trying to save him.
commissioner August 29, 2011 at 10:03 pm
My condolences go out to all that knew your friend.
I strongly disagree with you sir. Regardless of how skilled a rafter your friend was he gave up his concern for anyone to come in harms way when he got in the raft. Your friend had a choice to participate in extremely reckless and dangerous behavior. There were clear warnings out not to go in the Croton river. All those in the raft made a conscious decision to get in the raft when they were warned not to. This is similar to when someone gets in a car and drives at unsafe speeds. They not only risk their lives but those who share the roads and those who have to rescue them. I was at the dam before your friends got in the raft and saw the conditions of the river. I have still pictures of the conditions of the river and saw your friends preparing to leave and thought to myself somebody would get hurt. I witnessed the rescue attempts and tried to assist by using binoculars to try to locate anyone who might be missing. I use the river when it is safe and respect it when it is not. Again my condolences, this is a tragedy that could have been avoided.
Jock Bradley August 30, 2011 at 12:36 am
I remember a number of years ago when Peter and I worked together to save another kayaker. We spoke about the successful rescue afterwards and he said that he would rather drown, than to be the cause of someone getting hurt or killed who was trying to save him.
Peter made a choice and he paid for it with his life. Now he is being condemned by people who know nothing of him or the contributions he made to so many others. It appears to be more comfortable to sit in the high chair of sanctimony and pass judgement than it is to just be saddened by the loss of someone so good. There is nothing to be learned by this accident. It won't stop others from rafting or kayaking in high water any more than someone dying while surfing big waves, sky diving, mountaineering or extreme skiing will dull the appeal of those sports. Passing negative judgement beyond ones own mirror, serves no benefit and will only allow that person to feel better about themselves and only in their own eyes. I will celebrate my friends life and not second guess or condemn him for his choice. If true condolences are being wished, then for the sake of his children, please just leave it at that.
marcela August 30, 2011 at 12:57 am
Jock, I'm truly sorry for his needless death and your loss. Knowing that he had children that makes me even more upset. For their sake, he should have stayed out of the river like the immense mayority of people did. There was nothing to be gained by this act of extreme negligence and defiance of nature. By all means, celebrate his life but let's be honest and admit that their idea was not a good one for them, for those who had to risk their lives to save them, or the ones left without him.
Jock Bradley August 30, 2011 at 03:35 am
I live nearly 3,000 miles away and I'm a kayaker who has paddled a lot of class V whitewater. In other words I have skills in this sport. It would be far too easy for me to sit here and say it was foolish without knowing what Peter was thinking. Unless I stood on the bank of the river and knew my skills versus what I saw in the river, I would be unqualified to backseat quarterback as to whether or not it was wise run this stretch of river in those conditions. Hopefully Peter's critics are vastly better skilled than he was. Only then do you all have a voice worth listening to.
Roger Janssen August 30, 2011 at 03:53 am
Peter was a friend of mine, we were planning a trip with our girls (Betsy and Janice ). He leaves a son with whom he was very close, they loved adventure seeking together. You'll be missed Peter - Thanks for being in our lives ............Roger J.
RIP August 30, 2011 at 12:29 pm
How can you dare call them idiots? They did what they wanted to do, and i'm sure if they realized the result of what was going to happen than they would not have done it. For you to sit on here and call them idiots, when his very own daughter and family are reading this article and mourning their loss makes YOU an idiot, a HEARTLESS idiot. So go find somewhere else to leave your comments they are not wanted her. RIP.
George Datino August 30, 2011 at 02:36 pm
I am hoping someone who is an experienced whitewater rafter can answer this question. Is there a difference in a river that over the years experiences the volume of water that creates the conditions for the sport of whitewater rafting and a river that doesn't normally handle that volume of water?
Jonathan August 30, 2011 at 04:04 pm
My family has done whitewater rafting for years. My sons still do it. When you raft on rivers that are known for it the rapids and channels are known and mapped entities so you can plan your route to avoid trouble spots while maximizing enjoyment and difficulty. When a river is raging like this at 50mph, it takes on a life of it's own and everthing becomes unknown and extrmely dangerous. I doub't very much that any commercial rafting outfit would have allowed people on this river in these conditions. If these guys were as experienced as they claim, they clearly should have known better than to try a stunt like this. Emergency rescue people have better things to do in a storm like this than devote resources to a bunch of daredevils who mess up seeking a rush. The whole thing is mindbogglingly stupid.
Kryzténa Ana Fragata August 31, 2011 at 05:50 am
Should have, could have, would have, doesn't exist , there just is, and what is , is a tragic death.
If you have nothing nice to say don't say anything at all. This man's family, friends, and loved one are in enough pain & suffering without these cruel comments.
Bill Tuttle September 2, 2011 at 06:57 am
I was afriad this man had killed himself and left children behind,,,,I am sure the were in his thoughts as he fought for that final gasp of air and how his enjoyment took their fathers life from them. I do hope he was not so overconfident that his child/children were in the posse that he had brought to watch his brave deed and his death. It is too bad that this Dr and team with all this water and water rescue knowledge and equiptment was not helping flood victims throughout the county/state instead of costing these people a chance for help and taking all the manpower and rescue equiptment from the people who did not ask for the trouble they were in. Truly a shame. Children without father,,small town losing valuable equiptment and having to foot the bill of this on top of all the storm damage,,truly a shame. As long as he enjoyed himself I guess it's all good though.
Jock Bradley September 2, 2011 at 04:28 pm
In another forum one of the first responders that was on the scene stated that there were plenty of assets to handle any emergencies that might have come up.
Tell me Bill - what have you done to help the flood victims?
john September 3, 2011 at 01:38 am
Excuse me but I for one am getting sick and tired of all the excuses being made for the reckless actions of these men. I feel compassion for his family. I'm sure he was a lovely man and father, and it would have been better had it never happened. But the fact remains that my village could have lost three volunteer firemen and at least two police officers. It is irrelevant how skilled the rafters allegedly were. It is irrelevant whether the water was a Class V or Class Whatever. The area where these men went in is clearly posted.They ignored the postings. They ignored the National Weather Service which said that the storm was still a clear presence in our area and would not officially "pass" until after 7 pm that day. Ferrchrissake, they ignored the massive water flow pouring down from the dam itself. We have every right to complain about men who put our family members at risk. May he rest in peace but expecting us to be happy simply because more people aren't dead, is a bit much to ask.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Ossining-Croton-on-Hudson Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
CREAZZI UPHOLSTERY June 11, 2013 at 12:32 pm
IN BRANDETH ST
Krista Madsen (Editor) June 11, 2013 at 05:19 pm
Thanks for sharing this, I'll check into it!